Blog
How MDP Laryngoscopes Stack Up Against the Competition
COMPARISON CHART FOR REUSABLE HANDLES
| Features | MDP | Heine | SunMed | Teleflex | Welch
Allyn |
| Construction | Extremely durable German grade stainless steel and brass and chrome plated | High Quality Stainless steel | Strong durable stainless steel | 304-series stainless steel | |
| Design | Knurled design facilitates strong grip & prevents slipping | Knurled design facilitates strong grip & prevents slipping | Smooth finish ribbed design | Textured grip for regular handle and Ergonomic grip with silicone cushioning for rechargeable handle | Knurled Chrome Finish |
| Autoclavable
Cycles |
4000 standard cycles of 134°/4 minutes* | 4000 standard cycles of 134°C/4 minutes | 132°C/3 minutes for Gravity Autoclave
|
||
| Warranty | 5 years | 5 years | 5 years | 5 Years |
* STERILIZATION: Ethylene Oxide (EO) or Steam Autoclaving
COMPARISON CHART OF LIGHTING FOR REUSABLE
FIBER OPTIC HANDLE
- MDP offers three light options: LED, Halogen, and Xenon.
- LED consumes significantly less energy. 6.5 KW LED bulb output equals 50 KW Halogen bulb
- More energy converted to light rather than heat. 11.5 W LED bulb = 60 W conventional bulb
- A 2.5V LED is 3x brighter than 3.5V Halogen bulb
- LED bulb lasts 2000 times longer than Halogen and Xenon
Therefore, the market trend is towards LED lighting, and the comparison chart is
provided for fiber optic LED handles only.
| Parameter | MDP | Heine | Welch Allyn | SunMed | Teleflex |
| LED Bulb
Voltage |
2.5V for regular battery handle and 2.5V & 3.5V for rechargeable battery handles | 2.5V for regular battery handle and 2.5V & 3.5V for rechargeable battery handles | 2.5V for regular
& 2.5V & 3.5V rechargeable battery handles |
2.5 V | 1.5 V |
| Rechargeable Battery | Nickel Metal Hydride (NIMH) battery | NIMH or Lithium Ion | Nickel Cadmium (Cadmium is toxic) | Lithium-ion battery | |
| Make | Germany* | Germany | Germany | ? | ? |
| Intensity of LED light in lux (lumen/m2) | 100,000 lux for 2.5 V LED | 100,000 lux for 2.5V LED | |||
| Bulb
Warranty |
50,000 Hrs. | 50,000 Hrs. | 50,000 Hrs. | 35,000 Hrs. | >10000
Hrs. |
* If brighter light is required, LED bulb from Taiwan could be provided
COMPARISON CHART FOR DISPOSABLE FIBER
OPTIC LED LARYNGOSCOPE
| Parameter | MDP | Heine | Welch Allyn | SunMed | Teleflex | |
| Handle | Aluminum* or stainless steel | Plastic or combination of handle shell and battery inserts | Self contained unit w/smooth finish | Reinforced Plastic Handle | ||
| Blade | Stainless steel | Plastic | Plastic or solid metal Blade | |||
| LED Bulb Voltage | 2.5 V | 2.5 V | 2.5 V | 2.5 V | 2.5 V | |
| Bulb Make | China | China | China | China | China | |
| Intensity of LED light in Lux (lumens/m2) | ||||||
| Warranty | 2 year shelf- life | 3-year shelf- life | ||||
- Unlike the competition, MDP disposable aluminum handle comes with batteries and LED lamp sealed inside the handle. Batteries and Lamp unit cannot be replaced